Posted on November 14, 2007 12:59 AM
Torsell to serve almost six years
Former Penn State student Anthony Torsell remained quiet when sentenced to nearly six years in prison yesterday for speeding through a downtown crosswalk in the early hours of Oct. 28, 2006, forever altering the lives of two young men.
Centre County Judge Thomas Kistler sentenced Torsell to four to eight years in prison for killing visitor Richard Smith, 21, and one year and eight months to three years and four months for critically injuring student Aaron Stidd when Torsell drove drunk through the South Atherton Street and West Beaver Avenue intersection.
A jury decided that while Torsell was behind the wheel of a Buick Skylark, he negligently drove down the two men, hurling their bodies 97.5 and 169 feet, respectively.
J. Stidd, Aaron's father, said he and his family were pleased with the judge's decision. However, he said he was disappointed with the defendant's lack of remorse.
"He is the same hedonistic individual that was behind the wheel that night," he said, adding that what little guilt Torsell expressed was nothing more than a "smokescreen."
After the sentence was announced shortly after 10 a.m., Torsell was ushered out of the courtroom by deputies, his family following quickly after.
"I think Anthony Torsell will make the best of his life," his attorney, Joseph Amendola said after the sentencing.
Amendola said he prepared his client for the maximum sentence -- 10 to 20 years -- and was surprised to hear Kistler's ruling.
"I think [Kistler] is well within his discretion," Amendola said. "I don't see sentencing as an issue," he added, referring to grounds for an appeal.
Kistler heard pleas from both the defense and prosecution before handing down his decision.
The Stidds' pastor, Suzanne Morelli, spoke to the judge on behalf of the family.
"I do not see the hatred that has been brought up here -- I see deep loss, deep grieving," she said, retorting Amendola's earlier claim that the Stidds and Smiths have shown anger toward his client.
Torsell also spoke to the judge, expressing deep regret and slightly changing his claim to responsibility.
"I understand fully what I have done and I take responsibility for my part, " he said yesterday. At a hearing last week, Torsell said he was "partially" at fault, and he "got caught up in a college binge drinking society."
Amendola admitted that Torsell's use of the word "partially" was a "poor choice of words."
"He wasn't depreciating his involvement," he added.
Torsell spoke directly to Kistler during his final plea and did not address the victims' families.
"No one will ever know how remorseful I am, how much my heart breaks and how I wish I could trade places," Torsell said to Kistler.
Centre County Assistant District Attorney Steve Sloane said Torsell was not taking enough responsibility for his actions and should have directly apologized to the Stidds and Smiths.
Amendola petitioned the judge to allow Torsell to serve his term in the Centre County Correctional Facility, where he would be allowed work release to help the Stidds with medical bills. However, for such a crime, state prison is mandatory.
Torsell will not have to pay restitution for Stidd's medical bills because they are taken care of through insurance and donations, Kistler said. However, he will have to pay $27,600 to the Stidd family to customize a vehicle capable of transporting Aaron.
Stidd remains unable to speak, walk or perform daily tasks. He expects to be released from a HealthSouth rehabilitation hospital on Dec. 3, but still has more than a decade-long battle of pain ahead, his parents said.
"Five years and eight months will pale in comparison to what Aaron deals with daily," J. Stidd said.
Kistler said the decision in this "profoundly sad" case was not easy.
Torsell had "two or three opportunities to stop what was going on," he said, adding that, "in the most conservative terms," the events that took place that night were something he has rarely seen.
Kistler said these two factors outweighed Torsell's background and strong character in his decision.
He offered the families one final thought.
"I can't do anything today that will offer you any solace or any comfort," he said. "We don't know how you've endured what you've endured."