1. Doesn't make you any more qualified than I to make any kind blanket statement unless you have played them all.
The point was that you weren't even addressing the right argument... You simply made up your own argument to argue against. I was correcting your mistake.
2. For someone who gets worked up because I suggested with the experience anyone who has play MP games on any system has come in contact with might be playing the MP game your playing right now. You don't seem to have very thick skin. Kind of hypocritical. Just calling you out on it.
I have no idea what you just said. That sentence isn't english. Please rephrase so I could understand.
3. Your right slo mo death shots so you can excited about how awesomely you blew or had your head blown off is all about a sense of accomplishment and camaraderie /sarcasm. While you might enjoy as I have had before a great match or two in MP. Think of this from someone who doesn't get that sense of camaraderie and all you are doing for 8 hours is killing the same person over and over again in different ways.
There is no slow motion death shots in BF4, so I don't know what you are talking about. Where are you coming up with 8 hours? You just outright made up two things and then attacked it. If you can't stay on topic and address my actual arguments, then you are wasting my time. I can't spend all day debating your fictional scenarios/concoctions. To add insult to injury, I don't even understand what point you are trying to make. It gets lost in the completely made up statements.
4. My only point is that just because you enjoy a different type of game more doesn't mean that everyone else's favorites are trash and everyone should be wondering what type of person can possibly enjoy them.
I am allowed to state my opinion just like you are allowed to state yours. You canNOT argue that my opinion is wrong just because you don't like it or the way that I say it.
Why less limited medium. Wouldn't it be the most unlimited way to tell a story. You can create a branching tale, or a very tight tale, you can give the player choices, or force them into action. It can be your story or their story. Heck new story you right could have 5 different approaches in games depending on how the content lends itself. If I was a writer would I want to write for a 20 million a year production in TV or 200 million dollar production in games?
Less for a few reasons. A book has the imagination as the limit. This is limitless. Video allows actual human actors, which brings the whole human connection thing. Games are limited by many things. It doesn't have the limitless imagination of a book nor a human component. It is limited by graphics and stymied by the game itself. You are artificially playing someone else's story.
I write a Truism about MP gaming and it's Hyperbole, yet you write the paragraph above this one and it's not? .01% really? That said. I played hours of BF1942, BF Vietnam (so much fun), BF2, BF2142 (underrated), and BF3. Vietnam being about the only one that didn't have the normal allotment of douches in it. Doesn't mean it was clean just not as big a group of players as the other ones. I find it even more laughable you would bring up TF2 and its mega troll laden existence, which between hacks and trolls during several points in it's life was damn near unplayable in MP's defense (one I note you don't need, I am unlike you, not suggesting people should avoid any of these games).
You making a purposely exaggerated statement which tries to take the debate in a random direction that holds no basis in reality. I, on the other hand, feel LITERALLY that there is such a statistically insignificant amount of worthwhile stories out in gaming, as to be near .01%.
TF2.. Hacks? Umm, no.
"Trolls"? I played on well admined servers, including a "community," as they call themselves, which I admined alongside them. Take a few minutes to find a quality server. Just like your above complaints, you have to do a tiny amount of work by spending a handful of minutes here and there to find quality servers. I could name you plenty that have literally zero troublemakers, and I haven't played in a year... This is a problem with your laziness, not the game or the people.
I wouldn't expect you to. You have to be avoiding all the good SP games make the generalizations you have. I like all sorts of entertainment. I read more books than most of my friends (though not nearly as much as I would like), during a given year am watching 10-20 different non-reality, non-game show, TV series. Also a big Movie aficionado with over 250 Blu-rays and 146 HD-DVD's. I love experiencing others people imaginations in as many forms of media available. Guess what? I disagree with your statement that SP games are a poor way of getting those tales to me. Once again you have demeaned people for their own personal enjoyment in a game play experience you didn't enjoy.
"You have to be avoiding all the good SP games make the generalizations you have." Umm, no I don't. I simply have higher expectations than you. You can't make up what you WISH that I have experienced, so that you could reiterate your opinion as being right.
Movies don't impress me either. They are bitesized, generally lackluster, money makers. This is why I specifically mentioned tv instead of movies. However, maybe 5% of movies have something of value, which is still way more than videogame stories.
Right off the bat I can say fine Bio Shock 2. But I could list dozens of fantastic FPS SP campaigns for you. Ones without a hint of RPG in them. It's not just about story, it's about pacing, it's about action, it about balance. Just because the plots themselves wouldn't stand up to a Best Picture script doesn't mean that the experience is therefore trash.
Cliched, obvious and overused barebone "stories" do NOT impress me. I am happy for you that you enjoy them. They bore me. Single player FPSs also offer zero challenge or compelling gameplay to me. It would be like trying to play soccer by myself, with some cliched "story" to pull me along. No thanks!
Corridor after corridor of gunning down mindless zombies(AI) with a tacked on "story" at intervals would end me as a gamer. Some people like mind numbingly repetitive and challengeless gameplay. There are whole genres around it(Diablo and clones). They bore me to tears.