Bullshit. It's true the flavor doesn't come from wood, it comes from peat, but to say it isn't smoky leaves me questioning whether or not you've ever had it.
It's not smokey, if you ever had ANY whiskey stored in pure oak then you'd know that.
Same goes for Lagavulin, it's not smokey in the taste either, it's just that you got shit taste.
I've probably drink more Laphroaig than every member of this forum combined, i was raised on it.
Now take a piss in a glass and drink that and compare it to any American fucking microbrew OR other version of their pissy beer and tell me that they don't taste piss in the same way Laphroaig tastes like smoke. You can't fucking compare tastes that don't fit together because your poor sense of taste can't do any better.
You want a whiskey that actually HAS smoke essence added to it, look no further than Bells, Latitude55 or even fucking Jack Daniels. Those ALL have smoke essences added, Laphroiag does NOT.