Ok, I see your points guys. But after browsing BMW forums, it seems as if some/most(?) owners love to replace their lights with clears. It does look nice and gives it that Euro style, but every time I see white indicator lights, I have a stereotypical image of riced up. Sorry, but that's the way I am.
And to answer your question - I would take the BMW. Probably the only upgrade I would do is add a cd player if it didn't have one. The stock look works great for me.