. She suggested reassessing Grace Under Pressure and Power Windows. So, I'm relaying that for you since you evidently aren't all that into them!
I now have all these on CD:
Retrospective 1974-1980
Rush (debut) 1974
Fly By Night 1975
Caress of Steel 1975
2112 1976
A Farewell to Kings 1977
Hemispheres 1978
Permanent Waves 1980
Moving Pictures 1981
Signals 1982
Grace Under Pressure 1984
Power Windows 1985
Presto 1989
Roll The Bones 1991
Counterparts 1993
I haven't got past 2112 yet.
Not into later albums, doesn't mean unfamiliar or not owning them. Rush one of my favorite bands of all time, so quite familiar with everything they have done. I've read a couple of Neil's books, watched the documentaries, etc...
For Rush, I prefer the 1975-1980 period that was more Prog Rock guitar dominated phase, with more mystical lyrics and long complicated songs.
I also love Moving Pictures and Signals. These are probably the biggest, most mainstream Rush Albums, and it captures the transition to a more synth heavy phase.
Grace Under Pressure, and especially Power Windows is when I started fining them less interesting with only one or two songs connecting on each album. Synths now seem to dominate guitar, songs are shorter, less prog, and lyrics are more mundane. It's Mainly only Red Sector A and Mystic Rhythms that connect for me from these two.
For someone new to Rush, I'd kind recommend the Three Albums starting with
Permanent Waves. This is kind of the end, and perhaps the most refined, and accessible Prog album. If you really like the longer more intricate prog songs then explore the back catalog.
Moving Pictures is the intersection between new and old Rush. This is often marked as the best Rush Album. I think overall because fans of Old Rush and New Rush both like this one.
Signals is perhaps the real beginning of Synth Heavy, Mundane topic Rush songs, but for whatever reason this one works for me, and I love it. While the next three just get less and less palatable for me. Together this Trio is the big shift and IMO are all among the best Rush Albums.