StormRider
Diamond Member
- Mar 12, 2000
- 8,324
- 2
- 0
Originally posted by: jman19
Originally posted by: StormRider
It's a stupid rule. Let's assume that it is true that women gymnast are at their prime when they are 14 years old. Why have a rule that prevents people at their prime from competing? Can you imagine this happening at other sports? "Ummm, I'm sorry, we don't allow running backs at their prime -- you have to wait until you are 34 years old before you are allow to play in the NFL".
What kind of sport is it that prevents little girls from competing for fear of getting your a$$ kicked by them? "Oh noessss! They have 14 year old girls on their team! We're gonna get our a$$ kicked!"
Who cares if it is stupid - if gymnists are better when younger, like you're suggesting, then everyone who isn't disobeying the rules is at a disadvantage to China. Whether or not the rule is stupid doesn't matter - China is cheating if these gymnists are younger than 16.
There's also the argument that older gymnasts have experience and maturity on their side. In prior world competitions, the China team had a reputation for choking because of their youth -- that's why our US Team won the World Championships against them.
I'm not sure we were at a disadvantage because at our qualifying meets there were lots of other gymnasts that were younger (but eligible according to the rules) than our current team. And yet we picked a bunch of older gymnasts to be on the final team.
Both Chellsie Memmel and Alicia Sacramone are 20 years old. Jana Bieger (alternate) is 19. Nastia Liukin is 18.
When I watched the women's qualifiers, I remember hearing the commentary about how valuable it is to have older teammates (such as Chellsie and Alicia) with international experience on the team to act as a calming influence on the younger members because sometimes the younger teammates will get rattled during competition. The Chinese team had a reputation for becoming unrattled and choking during competition. If age was the primary factor in winning, then we should have only picked 16 year olds as the final team members.