But as The Smoking Gun revealed, the Simses are trained actors, and Monifa appeared on "Pumpcast News" before!
Before moving to Hollywood, Calif. the couple founded a theater company, and Monifa won a dramatic acting competition by TNT. And in March 2011, Monifa appeared on "Pumpcast News," though she ran around the gas station instead of singing.
[Related: Max Greenfield Dishes on Schmidt's Fitness Routine, 'Veronica Mars' Kickstarter]
The couple insists that they did not plan the second appearance. "When it happened again, I said, 'I cannot believe it!'" Monifa Sims told The Smoking Gun. The show did not mention Monifa's previous time on the segment because producers didn't want the audience "to think we were actors and it was a 'plant,'" Will Sims explained.
"We weren't expecting this at all. But it's been a lot of fun. I'm happy that it's made a lot of people laugh," his wife added.