Originally posted by: LegendKiller
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
Originally posted by: LegendKiller
Originally posted by: Raduque
Maybe we should make futures trading of oil illegal?
So people who have legit reasons for doing so cannot do it?
There are thousands of good reasons why people should be able to hedge using oil futures and it is certainly a huge benefit to the world economy.
sometimes the legit business interests of people have to give way to the practical interests of people. IF speculators are causing this price hikes (and I'm not saying that they are), I think a moratorium on future trading would not be such a bad idea. At the very least, it will show whether they are the source or not.
This market has motored along for hundreds of years in some form or another. Modern futures markets have operated for more than a hundred years with no significant problem. There's only been one time in history that you've seen this type of problem, the Amsterdam Tulip bubble.
The actual futures aren't the real problem, it's a global capital pool that runs from one investment with loopholes to another. From 97-2001 it was the .bombs and the ability to pump and dump stocks. From 2001-2007 it was houses in the ability to pump and dump houses. Now it's futures.
In all cases, all three markets were just fine before everybody went "all in". Merely shutting down the market is a horrible solution, since businesses around the world depend on the futures market to hedge against all sorts of risks. You're cutting off your nose to spite your face.
Multitudes use futures, from your small-town farmer (crop futures) to airlines (fuel futures) to freight companies (fuel futures). All do them for legitimate reasons, reduction of volatility, locking in prices, management of cashflows and balance sheets, investor certainty...etc. Simply cutting them off would not only cause irreperable harm to the function of the financial markets, but would effectively add a massive jolt of volatility into the world markets and corporations.
What needs to happen is the CFTC with the SEC and other regulatory bodies need to close down loopholes (such as the London Loop), increase capital requirements for holding futures (for investment banks) and increase reporting (for all publicly held companies). Those 4 actions alone would deflate the bubble very quickly.
Speculation has a legitimate use in this market. It provides price discovery for all involved and also provides liquidity for people who actually NEED the market. However, due to loopholes and lack of regulation/reporting/limits, it can be abused.
Before advocating such extreme positions you might want to get educated on them a bit more. Extremist positions, such as yours, are quite uninformed and do nothing but cause problems.