- Aug 4, 2000
- 30,666
- 2,600
- 126
(I posted this in another thread but it might also be good here)
I've been wondering about this electrified car future we are supposed to heading for. I've been driving for over 30 years and I've been through a lot from dead car batteries, pushing cars that ran out of gas, calling AAA, etc.
Since people will do things like forget to plug in their car overnight that has a low charge and they barely make it to work on time but the car is dead or they are out somewhere and run out of juice short of charging station, what do they do?
Once everyone is expected to own an EV are you going to see stranded cars everywhere?
And what about mobile charging? Normally when you go to a gas station, it only takes about 5 minutes to fill up completely and be good for two weeks and 300+ miles. If there is an extended blackout are you just f-d?
But can you imagine sitting at the gas station for 20-40 minutes?!! I cant.
Edit 2/28/21 -
Here are other additional concerns with regard to EVs and why they will likely never work as a primary mode of transportation beyond mass transportation or urban centers :
1) Infrastructure problems and trip planning if you want to get on the freeway, especially during the holidays. Leave your EV at home and rent an ICE car.
2) EVs are damaging to the environment - Lithium batteries are not re-recyclable on a large scale, but attempts are being made to do so, so this may get better over time.
3) Expensive and difficult to repair - If you own an electric car, you can forget going to your local shop or fixing it inexpensively. Regardless of the type and the model, all-electric vehicles require specific maintenance and service procedures as well as extremely high safety standards. Shade tree mechanics need not apply.
4) Very dangerous fire hazard OR might kill a first responder - Servicing electric cars can be quite dangerous because most of the car’s mechanics consist of battery packs under high voltage. Also, in case of a fire, you can’t just put it out with water. You have to use a special fire extinguisher since the batteries burn at a much higher temperature.
Battery packs can burn for DAYS or can re-ignite on fire days later.
"High-voltage batteries can give electric shocks that can kill responders if touched" :
Edit 3/2/21
War against ICE transportation begins in earnest in CA:
I've been wondering about this electrified car future we are supposed to heading for. I've been driving for over 30 years and I've been through a lot from dead car batteries, pushing cars that ran out of gas, calling AAA, etc.
Since people will do things like forget to plug in their car overnight that has a low charge and they barely make it to work on time but the car is dead or they are out somewhere and run out of juice short of charging station, what do they do?
Once everyone is expected to own an EV are you going to see stranded cars everywhere?
And what about mobile charging? Normally when you go to a gas station, it only takes about 5 minutes to fill up completely and be good for two weeks and 300+ miles. If there is an extended blackout are you just f-d?
But can you imagine sitting at the gas station for 20-40 minutes?!! I cant.
Edit 2/28/21 -
Here are other additional concerns with regard to EVs and why they will likely never work as a primary mode of transportation beyond mass transportation or urban centers :
1) Infrastructure problems and trip planning if you want to get on the freeway, especially during the holidays. Leave your EV at home and rent an ICE car.
2) EVs are damaging to the environment - Lithium batteries are not re-recyclable on a large scale, but attempts are being made to do so, so this may get better over time.
3) Expensive and difficult to repair - If you own an electric car, you can forget going to your local shop or fixing it inexpensively. Regardless of the type and the model, all-electric vehicles require specific maintenance and service procedures as well as extremely high safety standards. Shade tree mechanics need not apply.
4) Very dangerous fire hazard OR might kill a first responder - Servicing electric cars can be quite dangerous because most of the car’s mechanics consist of battery packs under high voltage. Also, in case of a fire, you can’t just put it out with water. You have to use a special fire extinguisher since the batteries burn at a much higher temperature.
Battery packs can burn for DAYS or can re-ignite on fire days later.
"High-voltage batteries can give electric shocks that can kill responders if touched" :
NTSB Report: Electric Vehicle Fires Endanger Emergency Responders
Because of the way electric vehicle fires burn first responders are endangering themselves. The high-voltage lithium-ion battery fires can’t be
www.motorbiscuit.com
Edit 3/2/21
War against ICE transportation begins in earnest in CA:
A California city just voted to ban new gas stations as the state eyes an all-electric future
California plans to ban the sale of gas-powered cars by 2035. Petaluma's city council decided to outlaw the construction of new gas stations.
www.businessinsider.com
Last edited: