Yea, I've given up looking. I just pay the going price on ebay, and I'm fine with that lately. Goodwill is overrun by clothes and vhs tapes. Thrift stores have pretty much only ps2 sports games, and garage sales around here only serve the purpose of getting rid of baby clothes. Craigslist is full of people trying to put 5000 games on a wii. But, that's the price I pay for living in a military town. If it's not xbox 360, then the people around here don't care.
Goodwill and thrift stores have found out about eBay prices and got greedy so anything halfway decent gets shipped off to eBay or their own online auction site.
I've bought some stuff off eBay and most likely will be getting lots more because I'm going for complete in box NES/SNES collections, and at the very least complete in box RPG collections for all systems from NES to PS2.
But finding things in the wild once in a while for $1 helps compensate after spending $800 on a mint complete in box Earthbound and crap like that.
Garage sales are totally hit and miss, it's crazy. I almost didn't get the NES lot. Here's the story:
I almost didn't go, it was way out of the way from where I was headed next and the ad said something like "bikes, toys, kids stuff, games, etc" and didn't sound promising.
But I had some down time while garage sailing and stopped to get a bite while I surfed my phone for more listings. I had 1.5 hours until the one I was really waiting for (which actually said old NES and tons of games but he ended up not getting them out of storage) and I had nothing else to do. Also this sale started at 7 am and it was already 9 so if there was anything it was already gone.
With nothing else to do and reasoning it was only 20 mins there and back and wouldn't keep me from this other one I was waiting for, I decided to at least burn some time and maybe check out some other blind sales I might see along the way.
So I get there about 9:30 or so 2.5 hours after it started... sure wasn't going to find anything. The sale is taking place on their back patio, you walk through their car port through a utility room to get to it. And the first thing I see is a large table with a NES, a power pad, two of every first party controller, and 3 shoe boxes overflowing with games (62 carts total).
Too good to be true, it's already been picked I bet... I see Metroid, Ninja Gaiden, Contra, Super C, two copies of Super Mario Bros 3, Castlevania, lots of Konami and Capcom games... no it's all here!
Then I saw a sticker on the NES, $120. Sigh, eBayer, knew it was too good to be true. I asked if he could do any better, and said that I only wanted the Nintendo stuff, because it included a model 1 and 2 Sega Genesis and a handful of meh games.
He said he'd go down to $80.
So I ponder it, look the games over more. I'm like, looks like a bunch of duplicates here, Mario/Duck Hunt, Mario 2, Mario 3, Contra, etc and offered $60.
Sold.
Took 3 trips to the car to load it all.
My NES bare cart collection just gained like 50 games and is starting to look like a real collection now.