I'm super confused now. Is there something I could read about the various speeds of Sandy Bridge? Apparently it's much more complex than I thought. This whole 1.6GHz thing is news to me.
The 1.6GHz thing is likely EIST (Enhanced Intel SpeedStep). The multiplier drops below the set multiplier at idle to save energy.
The confusion comes from the reviews. The majority of Sandy Bridge reviews I've seen were on Asus boards, along with a few MSI and Intel boards. If those boards don't have an option to disable Turbo, then by the sheer number of those reviews it would appear to the casual web-surfer that Turbo is the
only way to overclock. This is apparently not the case.
Hopefully those boards that can only overclock via Turbo will get BIOS updates to allow fixed overclocking. In the meantime I'm going to go with a board that gives me full control, even if it means forgoing UEFI in the short term.
EDIT: looking at the Asus P8P67 Deluxe manual, it appears that Turbo can be disabled. From the reviews I read I got the impression that that option was not present at the time. That's good news.