Originally posted by: TheJian
I'm still thinking an E8400/E3110 is just as good or better. If I'm thinking about coming out of the box with no extra cost I like my odds at 3.6@400FSB with retail. I don't think 4ghz on retail is possible. Consider his chip is an engineering sample and look at the heatsink used. To hit 4.5 (on water) for anandtech with the E8500 it took 1.56v. A deadly cpu voltage. I'm thinking 6months to a year depending on temps even on water. That was rock stable for them. Again an ES chip. Not retail. Also look at the FSB speeds. How many people hit 2200FSB?
It's not a bargain anymore if you require water, and an excellent OCing board. I think a LOT of boards can hit 1600fsb easily and 3.6 retail isn't a stretch for many. That's a mighty cheap combo if we're talking budget king. The very mention of the word budget means they probably don't have money for a $60 heatsink correct? Water is out for that guy. You don't even get to what I consider REAL WATER, until $250 for a koolance (or around the same for a DIY kit of quality ($215-225?) - but koolance+300w heatsink is hard to beat for easy water).
This chip looks like great odds of 3.33, but crap at 4.0ghz. Again assuming a poor man. If he has money for a Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme maybe 4ghz is doable. I still think 3.6 out of the box with no other costs and not much special is playing the better odds. Also I think it will be more like $170/1000qty vs the 8400 being $183/1000qty. Sure they are through the roof right now, but I think you won't see more than $15 between them.
Don't forget about the 6MB cache either. Double does help. I'd say 3.8 to match the 3.6 E8400.
It's ironic you think the E8400 is 'better' for overclocking since it has a lower multiplier to begin with. The E8400 is a 9x333 chip, as opposed to 10x266 for the E7300. For any given clockspeed, the E8400 needs a higher FSB. To hit 4GHz, you need a 445MHz FSB on the E8400 as opposed to a 400MHz FSB on the E7300.
Most P35 boards easily exceed 500MHz FSB with a dual core CPU, so 4GHz (10 x 400) on the E7300 shouldn't be a problem provided the silicon itself is capable of such speeds.
The official 1k tray price is $133, not some $170 figure you imagined. These chips are Allendale replacements, they won't be in the same price range as the E8xxx chips.
All the 'issues' you pointed out with this chip are totally unfounded.