I have been following this since I got my Wink hub but did not feel a need to post until now. I have been questioning Wink on Twitter about there lack of support for generic z-wave devices and their general lack of communications. Tonight I went to Twitter to ask about firmware 00.56 and a changelog only to find that Wink has blocked me on Twitter.
How is that for "customer service"? I saw earlier posts here about the CEO being childish but to block your customers is a bit over the line I think.
Bottom line, it doesn't work as advertised. A lot of people are transitioning over to SmartThings:
http://community.smartthings.com/t/how-easy-to-transition-from-wink-to-smartthings/5741/8
Also, mixed thoughts on the Twitter block. Technically, Twitter, for companies, is more of an advertising medium rather than a place for tech support, unless they specifically set up an account for that purpose (like
@LinksysCares). Not that I'm defending them, but airing issues in public that would put them in a negative light isn't really the ideal way for a response, especially since they've specifically stated they only have minimal generic Z-wave support & officially only support Wink Certified products. I've had mixed responses myself to them on Twitter & have found email is better for communicating with the company, although sometimes the responses are fast & sometimes they take awhile. And while I'd like them to have things like an official web interface & Windows phone support, they have made no official statement on that front and so it is what it is - this is the product they offer, today, right now, and I can't really expect more features if that's not what they are advertising.
I think we have to accept them as they are, and take a realistic look at their performance over the last 6 months. I don't want to make any personal attacks, but their CEO does appear to be more...relaxed...than other CEO's, and that appears to filter down to their communications, support, uptime, and general product & service reliability. Historically, customers have not reviewed their products very well either:
Wink Hub: 3 stars out of 381 reviews
Tripper sensors: 3.5 stars out of 19 reviews
Aros Smart A/C: 3 stars out of 250 reviews
Wink Relay: 3 stars out of 10 reviews
Spotter: 2 stars out of 64 reviews
Pivot Power Genius: 2 stars out of 17 reviews
Nimbus dashboard: 2 stars out of 6 reviews
My enthusiasm for a Wink-connected system has gone down quite a bit. While I still like the system, the hiccups are annoying. I have given up on scheduling my lights. People are still struggling getting the Hubs setup out-of-the-box, as well as with firmware updates. The service still goes down because it is cloud-based. Half of the product line has issues, as is evident from the poor reviews linked above. I didn't mind investing in some of the initial Wink equipment because of the promise it had, but I'm definitely not willing to spend $300 on a Relay when it only has an average of 3-star reviews, with most people saying that it's not ready for primetime yet. I don't want the upgrades I put in my house, which I use every single day, to be half-baked.
I don't want to turn this into a whine-fest, because generally, the system does work pretty good. However, new things are on the horizon, specifically the SmartThings v2 hub, and I am looking forward to what that has to offer. However, this time, I will be smarter & let someone else be the guinea pig so that I don't feel like I'm wasting my time & money on a system that isn't reliable. I've enjoyed tinkering with my Wink equipment, but I'd also really like it to work at least 99% of the time, which it does not, and it's hard to sell your non-techie family members on more equipment when the stuff you have already doesn't play nice sometimes.
I agree that transparency would be a good thing. For starters, setting up a Twitter support account & creating a public forum would be huge steps in the right direction for improving customer communications. Adding detailed changelogs to the firmware updates would help as well. Since they are big into letting people design stuff (under the Quirky brand), it'd be nice to have a section of the forum to vote on the features that need the most attention & new features that should be added, i.e. a web GUI, Windows phone support, and so on. Everyone understands that new companies have issues, especially since we know they were more or less rushed to the market, but they keep releasing new products & not fixing the issues they have, and even those new products (like the Relay & Tripper) are getting the same poor reviews as the existing older stuff. And then we have those oddly sexualized commercials with the weird robot butlet, but again, that's a whole different discussion