Which one of this two?

[Sheik Yerbouti]

and this is why they are both doing well, why there's Coke and Pepsi, Honda and Toyota, Laverne and Shirley...

 

[bunnyfubbles]

TF2 is far too lenient when it comes to teamwork. Therefor I choose L4D.

 

[zerocool84]

Originally posted by: bunnyfubbles
TF2 is far too lenient when it comes to teamwork. Therefor I choose L4D.

TF2 is entirely different every time you play. Some teams you play against will be weak and not need that much strategy while there are some good teams you play against that need a great deal of team work. TF2 is too different and varied from L4D to even compare them with the classes to learn and such. L4D has the same 2 maps and strategies while TF2 has basically an infinite amount of maps with an infinite amount of strategies with classes thrown in. Many people just wanna shoot and kill stuff and L4D is great in that aspect. Some people don't mind learning a multitude of maps and different classes and TF2 is great in that aspect. TF2 takes a hell of a lot longer to learn than L4D.

 

[RallyMaster]

I take Battlefield 2 over both.

 

[Sacraster]

L4D for me

 

[bunnyfubbles]

Originally posted by: zerocool84

Originally posted by: bunnyfubbles
TF2 is far too lenient when it comes to teamwork. Therefor I choose L4D.

TF2 is entirely different every time you play. Some teams you play against will be weak and not need that much strategy while there are some good teams you play against that need a great deal of team work. TF2 is too different and varied from L4D to even compare them with the classes to learn and such. L4D has the same 2 maps and strategies while TF2 has basically an infinite amount of maps with an infinite amount of strategies with classes thrown in. Many people just wanna shoot and kill stuff and L4D is great in that aspect. Some people don't mind learning a multitude of maps and different classes and TF2 is great in that aspect. TF2 takes a hell of a lot longer to learn than L4D.

You really do not come across sounding as if you have played a whole lot of L4D Vs. that was really competitive.

TF2 most certainly is a better game when it comes to finding a good casual pub, but when it comes to a game of balanced teams, L4D really raises the bar when it comes to intimate coordination.

 

[mb]

TF2 by far.

 

[HeXploiT]

TF2 but really...you need both these games.

 

[PepePeru]

TF2. L4D needs new content.
L4D is fun, but TF2 has so much more replay-ability, at the moment.

 

[Drako]

No contest - TF2. I've already stopped playing L4D.

 

[SpunkyJones]

L4D, I just can't get into TF2, even though I absolutely loved TFC.

 

[BurnItDwn]

Left 4 Dead was fun for about 1 or 2 hours before it got boring.
Team Fortress 2 lasted much longer. (though it didn't hold my attention nearly as well as TF did for Quake, or TFC for HL did back in the day) ...

 

[pennylane]

Yes to TF2.

 

[Oyeve]

Originally posted by: pennylane
Yes to TF2.

Ditto.

 

[sthaznpride17]

TF2. My roomate and I got bored of L4D fairly quickly, even playing versus. We never get bored of TF2 though.

 

[KeithTalent]

Hmmmm, tough decision...wait, no it's not, TF2 FTMFW!

KT

 

[jdelrio22]

I would say Left 4 Dead. It seems like it would get boring at first but the game can be so dynamic at times - for example people can die in so many different ways and the game changes a lot depending on teamwork from your team vs. the other team. While the goal is to get from A to B - how you get there can change depending on the other players with you.

 

[zerocool84]

Originally posted by: bunnyfubbles

Originally posted by: zerocool84

Originally posted by: bunnyfubbles
TF2 is far too lenient when it comes to teamwork. Therefor I choose L4D.

TF2 is entirely different every time you play. Some teams you play against will be weak and not need that much strategy while there are some good teams you play against that need a great deal of team work. TF2 is too different and varied from L4D to even compare them with the classes to learn and such. L4D has the same 2 maps and strategies while TF2 has basically an infinite amount of maps with an infinite amount of strategies with classes thrown in. Many people just wanna shoot and kill stuff and L4D is great in that aspect. Some people don't mind learning a multitude of maps and different classes and TF2 is great in that aspect. TF2 takes a hell of a lot longer to learn than L4D.

You really do not come across sounding as if you have played a whole lot of L4D Vs. that was really competitive.

TF2 most certainly is a better game when it comes to finding a good casual pub, but when it comes to a game of balanced teams, L4D really raises the bar when it comes to intimate coordination.

Left 4 Dead is just too boring cus it's the same stuff over and over even when you are playing against good people.

 

[Jabbernyx]

Originally posted by: bunnyfubbles
TF2 is far too lenient when it comes to teamwork. Therefor I choose L4D.

Try winning Baloon Race without teamwork...