No Papa John's here, so I can't judge theirs, but Domino's is probably the WORST "store-bought" pizza I've ever had. Only had one Sbarro pizza and wasn't impressed at all, and Pizza Hut just seems far too greasy for my tastes.
We have Mountain Mike's which is OK, Me & Ed's which is better, and one lone remaning Round Table which kicks all their asses.
In one of the neighboring towns, (maybe a 15 mile drive) there is the only GodFather's Pizza in the area...Not bad, but not great either.
Seems like the independently owned neighborhood pizza joints can't compete against the prices of the chain pizza shops and have been folding left & right lately.