X1900XTX or 7900GTX

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

VooDooAddict

Golden Member
Jun 4, 2004
1,057
0
0
You can't really go wrong with either the X1900XT(X) or 7900GTX.

If you are focused primarily on speed without AA and you don't have a strong preference on the Driver Control Panels, heat, power draw, and noise. Then go with which ever card has the better deal at the time of purchase.

Personally, I build SFF systems and the 7900's better cooling, noise, and power draw are enough of a factor that I recommend it over the X1900's for SFF and microATX systems. Standard tower with a beefy Power supply and adequate cooling ... it's all down to the $$'s.

 

CaiNaM

Diamond Member
Oct 26, 2000
3,718
0
0
Originally posted by: anandtechrocks
Yes, I did put an 3rd party heatsink on it, but the X1800XT was too much for my VF700 to handle. So I had to buy a CPU heatsink (Zalman 7000ALCU) which still has trouble keeping up with the heatWith the stock heatsink and no overclocks my X1800XT would hit load temperatures around 80C, which is far to high in my opionion (not to mention the noise of the heatsink fan)..

i've had mine running 690/1700 from the day i got it, and even during the recent heat wave when room temp was in the mid/upper 80's I have had no issues whatsoever with the stock cooling.

Personally I don't see the hype around ATI's "better image quality." They both look very nice to me (I actually prefer nVidia's AA), but I do agree that the 7900GTX stutters a lot more.

aside from the easily seen difference in texture quality (not to mention the ability to do HDR+AA concurrently in oblivion, for example), as stated there's less "shimmering" (tho in certain cases this can show up using the x1k as well)... perhaps you should adj your driver settings to take advantage of the IQ benefits ati offers?

i'm really hoping nv corrects these issues w/ g80, but that's another subject...

 

Keysplayr

Elite Member
Jan 16, 2003
21,211
50
91
Originally posted by: Elfear
Originally posted by: Nightmare225
Nvidia's competitor to the XTX is the 7950GX2, and its nearest it's pricepoint, so that's not really a fair comparison. In that kind of fight, the GX2 would kick the XTX's keister.


Uhhhh

Cheapest prices I could find doing a quick search.

$570 7950 GX2

$440 7900GTX

$417AR X1900XTX

The 7950 GX2 may be a competitor but it is no where near the same price. Even the XTX's direct competitor, the 7900GTX, is more money at this point.

Here you go Elfear. GX2 for 499.00 at the egg.

Still 80.00 more than that XTX after the rebate, but still 70.00 less than monarchs price isn't insignificant.


WOW!!! did you see this? X1900XTX 339.00 after 100.00 mail in rebate!

 

n7

Elite Member
Jan 4, 2004
21,281
4
81
Neither.

Get the X1900XT, as mentioned, & spend a little extra on a better quieter cooler.
 

confused1234

Banned
Jun 17, 2006
1,120
0
0
"If I had the money I'd go with the 7900GTX. The 7900GTX almost always has equal or better performance than the X1900XT, and it has a very high quality heatsink that helps it stay silent and cool. I hate how hot ATIs new video cards run, for example, I had to mount a Zalman 7000 ALCU to my X1800XT to keep it running stable during these hot summer months, and the X1900XT is even hotter..."

uh no.. my x1900xt idle at 40c and loads at 60c. and is quiet
 

imported_Sincity

Senior member
Dec 24, 2005
404
0
0
For some reason I have been locked into the grips of Nvidia's clutches. Every video card I have owned (GF2 to 7900GTX) has been an Nvidia. Even if some of the ATI counterparts performed better.

So, I guess I am partial to the 7900GTX:thumbsup:
 

imported_Crusader

Senior member
Feb 12, 2006
899
0
0
Originally posted by: Sincity
For some reason I have been locked into the grips of Nvidia's clutches. Every video card I have owned (GF2 to 7900GTX) has been an Nvidia. Even if some of the ATI counterparts performed better.

So, I guess I am partial to the 7900GTX:thumbsup:

As am I. I prefer Nvidias driver support (Anything But CCC )
NVs drivers are still understated in their overall superiority to ATIs, esp with CCC around.

Not to mention you get a cooler/quieter/less power hungry card that has the SLI option. While the XTX only has Crossfire (which isnt as good as SLI) and runs at XT speeds when using Crossfire.

Also, the vendors for Nvidia cards are vastly superior.
Evga/XFX/BFG are impossible to beat. Lifetime warranty, with proven excellent service from BFG and Evga.

I dont know about you, but I really like the idea of a great warranty, from companies that are VERY fast when I spend $400+ on a video card.

I refuse to buy anything NOT from Evga or BFG if its my buck. I want that warranty and I dont care if its ATI or Nvidia.. not getting anything else.
Thats how great Evga and BFG are.

The IQ differences are miniscule, to exaggerate the issue.
And Nvidia has superior AA with 8xS (which does texture and geometry AA). In the end, IQ is generally considered a wash. And the NV drivers have been proven to do more "work" on a given scene than ATI (which skimps and attempts to skate off as easy as possible).
Its also nice along with having the great service/warranty, to have a card you dont need to change the heatsink/fan units on because they are already quiet. Esp the GTX. :thumbsup:
 

Gstanfor

Banned
Oct 19, 1999
3,307
0
0
Originally posted by: thilan29
Originally posted by: anandtechrocks
If I had the money I'd go with the 7900GTX. The 7900GTX almost always has equal or better performance than the X1900XT, and it has a very high quality heatsink that helps it stay silent and cool. I hate how hot ATIs new video cards run, for example, I had to mount a Zalman 7000 ALCU to my X1800XT to keep it running stable during these hot summer months, and the X1900XT is even hotter...

If you overclock your card shouldn't you expect to put an aftermarket cooler on it??

If you were running it at stock I doubt it would be unstable even in the summer. Granted the stock heatsink is louder but it stayed fairly cool when not everclocked didn't it?

No, you shouldn't expect to, and the 7800/7900 GTX cooler is an excellent example of not needing to. Most video card makers get away with supplying utter cr@p for cooling solutions IMO.
 

Vesper8

Senior member
Apr 29, 2005
253
0
0
i own a x1900xtx and it totally pwns

as some have mentionned it's only problem was overheating and sound of factory fan.

that was effortlessly and inexpensively solved by strapping an accelero x2 on it and setting it to run at 100% speed ALL the time. The fan is incredibly SILENT even at 100% and my card never even gets close to getting hot now. I'm sure i could OC it too without a problem but I'm not gonna OC a card that cost me 700$ cdn

least not for a year at least
 

CaiNaM

Diamond Member
Oct 26, 2000
3,718
0
0
Originally posted by: Crusader
As am I. I prefer Nvidias driver support (Anything But CCC )
NVs drivers are still understated in their overall superiority to ATIs, esp with CCC around.

while it's fine your personal preference is for nv drivers (i too favor nv drivers), there is absolutlely nothing wrong with CCC (and if you really don't like CCC due to mem usage or slow load time, you can install w/o CCC).

Not to mention you get a cooler/quieter/less power hungry card that has the SLI option. While the XTX only has Crossfire (which isnt as good as SLI) and runs at XT speeds when using Crossfire.

heh.. a 7900GT is not quiet by any stretch of one's imagination.

Also, the vendors for Nvidia cards are vastly superior.
Evga/XFX/BFG are impossible to beat. Lifetime warranty, with proven excellent service from BFG and Evga.

XFX? lol.. just google XFX and you will fine pages of complaints.

EVGA does indeed have good service, however they've been selling broken cards for months (self-admittedly).

BFG I'd concur. I've had 3 of their products (still have 2) and the 2 times I've had contact with them they were excellent.


[/quote]I dont know about you, but I really like the idea of a great warranty, from companies that are VERY fast when I spend $400+ on a video card.[/quote]

Sapphire and Powercolor have top notch service as well (I've actually used Powercolor's, and there were as professional as BFG).

I refuse to buy anything NOT from Evga or BFG if its my buck. I want that warranty and I dont care if its ATI or Nvidia.. not getting anything else.
Thats how great Evga and BFG are.

unfortunate for you; though that statement does show your bias and narrow point of view.

The IQ differences are miniscule, to exaggerate the issue.

while the rest of you post was simply biased, this statement is a lie. having pc's with a 6800gt and 7800gs right next to me, the difference is easily noticeable. i'd even go as far as to say 90% of the people on these forums who have had both products would agree with me.

And Nvidia has superior AA with 8xS (which does texture and geometry AA). In the end, IQ is generally considered a wash. And the NV drivers have been proven to do more "work" on a given scene than ATI (which skimps and attempts to skate off as easy as possible).

hmm.. angle dependant AF, lower quality default modes.. perhaps you should check your facts again.

Its also nice along with having the great service/warranty, to have a card you dont need to change the heatsink/fan units on because they are already quiet. Esp the GTX. :thumbsup:

i'm running my stock heatsink, fan (while overclocking ) and am doing just fine, thank you. that said, the GTX does have an elegant cooling solution, if you're willing to dish out that kind of money to get the same performance possible with the GT.....
 

imported_Crusader

Senior member
Feb 12, 2006
899
0
0
Originally posted by: CaiNaM
Originally posted by: Crusader
As am I. I prefer Nvidias driver support (Anything But CCC )
NVs drivers are still understated in their overall superiority to ATIs, esp with CCC around.

while it's fine your personal preference is for nv drivers (i too favor nv drivers), there is absolutlely nothing wrong with CCC (and if you really don't like CCC due to mem usage or slow load time, you can install w/o CCC).

Glad to see we agree.. its pretty tough not to on this one. As its blatantly obvious which is superior.
But for the best out of the box experience, NV is the way to go. To not use CCC and gain all the features of ATI is a pain.. and thats just not right.
Best OOTB experience is the way to go.

Not to mention you get a cooler/quieter/less power hungry card that has the SLI option. While the XTX only has Crossfire (which isnt as good as SLI) and runs at XT speeds when using Crossfire.

heh.. a 7900GT is not quiet by any stretch of one's imagination.
Certainly no louder than that X1900 dustbuster. Still very quiet though.
I've owned a 7800GT, 7900GT and 7900GTX. The GTX cooler is the best in the industry hands down. But the GT is a great budget solution, and not loud.

Also, the vendors for Nvidia cards are vastly superior.
Evga/XFX/BFG are impossible to beat. Lifetime warranty, with proven excellent service from BFG and Evga.

XFX? lol.. just google XFX and you will fine pages of complaints.

EVGA does indeed have good service, however they've been selling broken cards for months (self-admittedly).

BFG I'd concur. I've had 3 of their products (still have 2) and the 2 times I've had contact with them they were excellent.

Well I dont like XFX that much either. I only personally buy Evga and BFG due to great past service from both.
But XFX does have double lifetime warranty, something no ATI card offers.


I dont know about you, but I really like the idea of a great warranty, from companies that are VERY fast when I spend $400+ on a video card.

Sapphire and Powercolor have top notch service as well (I've actually used Powercolor's, and there were as professional as BFG).
Yup but with ATI you have two choices.
Buy a HIS with quiet factory cooler and get horrible service and warranty (1 year). Or get another brand on the ATI side and get the dustbuster with a lifetime warranty, of which you void when you replace the cooler.
With Evga or BFG, you dont need to make those compromises.
Lifetime warranty is FAR more useful than slightly better AF. Not much good if your card dies and you dont see ANY AF
This stuff is simply getting too expensive to be paying $400+ for and NOT getting a lifetime warranty and a quiet cooler.

I refuse to buy anything NOT from Evga or BFG if its my buck. I want that warranty and I dont care if its ATI or Nvidia.. not getting anything else.
Thats how great Evga and BFG are.

unfortunate for you; though that statement does show your bias and narrow point of view.

Wrong. Evga and BFG ARE great. Thats not a narrow point of view, do a search and see what people think of those two companies product/service.
Its too bad EVGA or BFG dont support ATI, many people stand by me on that statement. Nothing narrowminded there, unles you dont like the truth.

The IQ differences are miniscule, to exaggerate the issue.

while the rest of you post was simply biased, this statement is a lie. having pc's with a 6800gt and 7800gs right next to me, the difference is easily noticeable. i'd even go as far as to say 90% of the people on these forums who have had both products would agree with me.

Yeah and I've had far more Nvidia cards than you have and I'm telling you the IQ difference isnt worth stabbing yourself samuri-style in the stomach for, at all.

And Nvidia has superior AA with 8xS (which does texture and geometry AA). In the end, IQ is generally considered a wash. And the NV drivers have been proven to do more "work" on a given scene than ATI (which skimps and attempts to skate off as easy as possible).

hmm.. angle dependant AF, lower quality default modes.. perhaps you should check your facts again.
Wow, slightly better AF.. and lowe quality default modes? Who cares? Thats why we have adjustments in the drivers.. are you not capable of setting the IQ and performance to your liking? The way its setup by default runs great.. in fact all optimizations are turned off by default in the 84.21s that I run.

Its also nice along with having the great service/warranty, to have a card you dont need to change the heatsink/fan units on because they are already quiet. Esp the GTX. :thumbsup:

i'm running my stock heatsink, fan (while overclocking ) and am doing just fine, thank you. that said, the GTX does have an elegant cooling solution, if you're willing to dish out that kind of money to get the same performance possible with the GT.....

Yeah and if you watercool a REALLY cheap video card you might be able to match the GT performance, who cares? I want my warranty intact when I spend $500 on a card.
Not a minimal performance improvement. Though I believe Evga does support overclocking under their warranty. Im happy with my cards performance and the cooler is very nice as well.
To each their own, but this thread wouldnt have any justice done to it if someone hadnt mentioned the difference between the two products warranty and vendor support. Its very important to me, and I'm sure to others also.
 

fierydemise

Platinum Member
Apr 16, 2005
2,056
2
81
OP just look at the majority of the posts in this thread, the general consensus is the X1900XT(X) don't be fooled by the nVidia fanboys who are in the distinct minority and go with the X1900XT(X). The only reason to choose the 7900GTX is if you have a small power supply (the X1900s are power hungry) or are concerned about noise. My suggestion would be, get the X1900XT and see how bad the noise is, if it is bad get an aftermarket cooler (I don't know enough to recommend one) otherwise you're fine. The Sapphire posted earlier is a good deal and will get you some very good service, if you are concerned about warranty (Sapphire only offers a 3 year) try Powercolor who offers a lifetime warranty however remember replacing the cooler will void the warranty.
 

imported_Crusader

Senior member
Feb 12, 2006
899
0
0
Yeah because we all know the majority always knows best right?
If I'm in company with Jesus and Ghandi, then I'm in good company.
The OP can make up his own mind, but Evga/BFG are hard to deny as factors.
 

RobertR1

Golden Member
Oct 22, 2004
1,113
1
81
Originally posted by: Crusader
Yeah because we all know the majority always knows best right?
If I'm in company with Jesus and Ghandi, then I'm in good company.
The OP can make up his own mind, but Evga/BFG are hard to deny as factors.


You're going to compare your vapid contributions on the video section of the anandtech messageboard to the humanitarian services of Jesus and Ghandi?

Thanks for the 5mins of laughter!

 

Ackmed

Diamond Member
Oct 1, 2003
8,498
560
126
Originally posted by: fierydemise
OP just look at the majority of the posts in this thread, the general consensus is the X1900XT(X)

Yep. The XTX is about $100 cheaper than the 7900GTX. And the XT is about $150 cheaper. Pretty easy choice to me.

Its funny seeing some people blow things up one way, and then try to say something else doesnt matter. There is a rather large IQ difference. There are several reviews that say this. Yet people who do not have, and have not seen the two cards claim IQ is the same. Then lie about Crossfire and say that a XTX will clock down to XT speeds. It doesnt, both cards will run at whatever speeds you put them at. Then claim that a 7900GT is "not loud", when its 50db, and very loud, according to reviews, and users. Pure lies and BS. But thats to be expected from some.



 

LittleNemoNES

Diamond Member
Oct 7, 2005
4,142
0
0
Cheapest x1900xt you can find and slap an accelero x2 cooler on it. Very inexpensive. However, dont use the ram thermal pads that come with hit since they have super glue (=you'll never be able to remove it). Use the stock pink ones cos otherwise its a pain.

lol yeah, all the nvidia trolls have to face up to the general consensus. BTW, I own and love my 7900GT but doesn't come through in oblivion like ATI does...even though I'm comparing it to crossfire

HDR+AA Owns you!
 

dug777

Lifer
Oct 13, 2004
24,778
4
0
Originally posted by: Crusader
Yeah because we all know the majority always knows best right?
If I'm in company with Jesus and Ghandi, then I'm in good company.

:laugh:

You sir, are without a shadow of doubt, the most determinedly delusional asshat i've ever encountered in Video...

:laugh:
 
sale-70-410-exam    | Exam-200-125-pdf    | we-sale-70-410-exam    | hot-sale-70-410-exam    | Latest-exam-700-603-Dumps    | Dumps-98-363-exams-date    | Certs-200-125-date    | Dumps-300-075-exams-date    | hot-sale-book-C8010-726-book    | Hot-Sale-200-310-Exam    | Exam-Description-200-310-dumps?    | hot-sale-book-200-125-book    | Latest-Updated-300-209-Exam    | Dumps-210-260-exams-date    | Download-200-125-Exam-PDF    | Exam-Description-300-101-dumps    | Certs-300-101-date    | Hot-Sale-300-075-Exam    | Latest-exam-200-125-Dumps    | Exam-Description-200-125-dumps    | Latest-Updated-300-075-Exam    | hot-sale-book-210-260-book    | Dumps-200-901-exams-date    | Certs-200-901-date    | Latest-exam-1Z0-062-Dumps    | Hot-Sale-1Z0-062-Exam    | Certs-CSSLP-date    | 100%-Pass-70-383-Exams    | Latest-JN0-360-real-exam-questions    | 100%-Pass-4A0-100-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-300-135-exams-date    | Passed-200-105-Tech-Exams    | Latest-Updated-200-310-Exam    | Download-300-070-Exam-PDF    | Hot-Sale-JN0-360-Exam    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Exams    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-JN0-360-exams-date    | Exam-Description-1Z0-876-dumps    | Latest-exam-1Z0-876-Dumps    | Dumps-HPE0-Y53-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-HPE0-Y53-Exam    | 100%-Pass-HPE0-Y53-Real-Exam-Questions    | Pass-4A0-100-Exam    | Latest-4A0-100-Questions    | Dumps-98-365-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-98-365-Exam    | 100%-Pass-VCS-254-Exams    | 2017-Latest-VCS-273-Exam    | Dumps-200-355-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-300-320-Exam    | Pass-300-101-Exam    | 100%-Pass-300-115-Exams    |
http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    | http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    |