That is it, a range toy. Who would use one for self defense? The thing is huge and uncontrollable. Same with the S&W 500. That thing looks like a revolver from a cartoon.
Last edited:
Never understood the obsession with DE - and I've fired one. They're notoriously picky with ammo, overly complex and heavy. In .44 mag, I'd take my model 29 *every* day of the week over that.
A range toy, I'd take it. But there are other range toys I'd like
Guys you've helped a bunch with picking out firearms in the past - most recently a shotgun for my needs.
Coming to you now asking about .45 ACP. I've already got 9mm and .380, but out of the .45s I have shot in the past, I liked shooting them the most. I'm having trouble decide what I'd really like to have. On one hand, I love 1911's and their history... their looks and their proven use over time. However, they generally have lower capacity and from what I've read, can be finicky at times. So, my other few choices were maybe a Glock 21/41, Sig 227, Hk45, FNP45.
I know that I'd like a full size gun, so 4+ inch barrel only. In my great communist state of CT, guns can't hold more than 10 rounds, so I think Glock 21 might be out by default, unless I get it in the 10round version (I think I can). I also think that FNP45 holds 13 by default, too. Something I need to consider.
Any other models I should be considering? If it matters, for 1911's I've been looking at any model that has a rail, 5'' barrel and non ambi safety, and full length guide rod. There's a bunch to name but I'm sure I don't need to list them all for you.
Guys you've helped a bunch with picking out firearms in the past - most recently a shotgun for my needs.
Coming to you now asking about .45 ACP. I've already got 9mm and .380, but out of the .45s I have shot in the past, I liked shooting them the most. I'm having trouble decide what I'd really like to have. On one hand, I love 1911's and their history... their looks and their proven use over time. However, they generally have lower capacity and from what I've read, can be finicky at times. So, my other few choices were maybe a Glock 21/41, Sig 227, Hk45, FNP45.
I know that I'd like a full size gun, so 4+ inch barrel only. In my great communist state of CT, guns can't hold more than 10 rounds, so I think Glock 21 might be out by default, unless I get it in the 10round version (I think I can). I also think that FNP45 holds 13 by default, too. Something I need to consider.
Any other models I should be considering? If it matters, for 1911's I've been looking at any model that has a rail, 5'' barrel and non ambi safety, and full length guide rod. There's a bunch to name but I'm sure I don't need to list them all for you.
Which model do you have for 1911? any experience shooting any of the other non 1911's I mentioned?If 10+ rounds are out then a 1911 is a great choice. I own a S&W 1911. It is really smooth for a pistol. I'm a big fan of rifles so that is my primary gun type when going to the range. But every once in awhile will bring the 1911.
My favorite .45 is HK's HK45. For 1911, take a look at Nighhawk custom and Wilson Combat.
Which model do you have for 1911? any experience shooting any of the other non 1911's I mentioned?
http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/...57754_757752_757751_ProductDisplayErrorView_Y
The laser is neat feature. But I never use it.
I have not shot any of the guns on your list. But I have shot a para 1911 and felt it wasn't as smooth as my 1911 if that helps.
Any non 1911's besides HK45, Glock 41/21, M&P45, etc that I should be aware of that fits that price range?
I don't remember 100% but I thought I counted both of those out because they didn't have rails on any of their models... But I've looked at so many now I can't remember.Sig P220. If I were you I'd just get a 1911 though. I have a Springfield Range Officer, you should be able to find them for $700-800. Ruger's 1911 is also very good, it's a bit cheaper.
Springfield XD/XDM? You can get the XD service compact if you don't want to be arbitrarily gimped on capacity: 4" barrel and 10rds by default.
CZ 97B should also be a good option. BD model if you just want a decocker w/o manual safety.
z1ggy,
Have you thought about looking at the Sig P320?
I had not, but it certainly seems to fill all my needs. Most Sig's tend to be in the $900-1000+ range... Why is this one much less expensive?
Short version: polymer frame. SIG Pros go for $450ish but you won't find one in .45.
I had not, but it certainly seems to fill all my needs. Most Sig's tend to be in the $900-1000+ range... Why is this one much less expensive?
Which model do you have for 1911? any experience shooting any of the other non 1911's I mentioned?
Ever shot any other 1911s like Taurus, RIA, Para, etc?
Oh, I most certainly will consider it.You should really look at used TBH. Gun forums especially. Last summer I picked up a used P220 in great shape for $550, ended up reselling it a few months later for $500 because it just didn't appeal to me the way I expected.
RIA is coming along pretty well in the gun world, and is worth thinking about seriously. Not sure on Para. I'd *never* trust a Taurus. My info is a few years old now, but I've seen too many horror stories from them.
With 1911s, you get out what you put in. My Dan Wesson is around $1300 new, and a GREAT 1911. (it's also a concealed carry gun - so shorter magazine, 4.25" barrel vs 5" - so you can stay above 4" and not be full size.)
Not to say a $800 S&W or Springfield (or RIA) isn't good, but it isn't as smooth running; the $3000 1911s are insane, but at around $1000 you get better fitting slides and such.
Springfield customer service is excellent.
I have 2 springfield 1911s and they are great guns.
Holy crap that guy has quite the collection!
RIA is coming along pretty well in the gun world, and is worth thinking about seriously. Not sure on Para. I'd *never* trust a Taurus. My info is a few years old now, but I've seen too many horror stories from them.
With 1911s, you get out what you put in. My Dan Wesson is around $1300 new, and a GREAT 1911. (it's also a concealed carry gun - so shorter magazine, 4.25" barrel vs 5" - so you can stay above 4" and not be full size.)
Not to say a $800 S&W or Springfield (or RIA) isn't good, but it isn't as smooth running; the $3000 1911s are insane, but at around $1000 you get better fitting slides and such.
obligatory 1911 buyers guide repost
https://www.1911addicts.com/threads/buyers-guide-for-all-you-1911-addicts.511/