The Official MTG Thread - All MTG stuff in here

Page 17 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
We see what happens with a generic capitalistic algorithms in terms of controlling peoples minds when it comes to social media. Facebook is banned in China right? Twitter is banned in China. I dont get why you'd want a state sponsored near peer adversary to 1. data mine your citizens and 2. put them on an -to China- advantageous algorithm. Take YG and raild' for example, worst case is they're actual US citizens and they've simply been scooped up by propaganda.
Do you not understand the difference between China and the US? I mean seriously. China heavily censors the Internet, and has a kill switch to shut it down inside of China. Should the US do the same, since China is doing it?

It's sad you don't even understand why Facebook, Twitter, and such are banned in China. If you did, you wouldn't be using such an argument. China banning vehicles of US influences started long before Facebook and/or twitter ever existed. Why do you think that is? Why do you think China censors the Internet and has a kill switch to cut it off at anytime?

What information do you really think they can get from tik tok that they can't already get form hundreds of other sources, that gladly taken their money for it?

What about all the other China invested companies that are involved with every aspect of the US economy, and the very heart of our survival, all with the government's blessing? Why is nothing being done about those companies?
 
Last edited:

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
23,258
12,889
136
Do you not understand the difference between China and the US? I mean seriously. China heavily censors the Internet, and has a kill switch to shut it down inside of China. Should the US do the same, since China is doing it?

It's sad you don't even understand why Facebook, Twitter, and such are banned in China. If you did, you wouldn't be using such an argument. China banning vehicles of US influences started long before Facebook and/or twitter ever existed. Why do you think that is? Why do you think China censors the Internet and has a kill switch to cut it off at anytime?

What information do you really think they can get from tik tok that they can't already get form hundreds of other sources, that gladly taken their money for it?

What about all the other China invested companies that are involved with every aspect of the US economy, and the very heart of our survival, all with the government's blessing? Why is nothing being done about those companies?
Yes I do.

China is banning vectors of influence cause western way of living, society, is bad. Must keep domestic minds clean. Right? People might *get ideas*. Right?

So what you're advocating is for influence to only flow one way.

Come on.

1. Either way you wanna put it, in terms of access to information from social media and data mining, the fidelity of this data must necessarily be much much better if you own the source. No rockets involved here.
2. Influence. The algorithm. In hands of pure bred capitalism we've all seen how much they suck. That being said capitalism is not inherently evil and it's a know construct. A foreign hostile entity on the other hand... Look what Elmo has done with Twitter for example. Imagine someone competent wanting to create division and chaos.

What other Chinese companies have influence potential like tiktok on US soil?
 

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
Erhm. Yea. Ok. Uhm. Naaaaaah dude.
Evidence to the contrary? See that's the problem, you and other's are running with what the US government is saying could happen, with no evidence that it is happening at all.

Yes I do.

China is banning vectors of influence cause western way of living, society, is bad. Must keep domestic minds clean. Right? People might *get ideas*. Right?

So what you're advocating is for influence to only flow one way.

Come on.

1. Either way you wanna put it, in terms of access to information from social media and data mining, the fidelity of this data must necessarily be much much better if you own the source. No rockets involved here.
2. Influence. The algorithm. In hands of pure bred capitalism we've all seen how much they suck. That being said capitalism is not inherently evil and it's a know construct. A foreign hostile entity on the other hand... Look what Elmo has done with Twitter for example. Imagine someone competent wanting to create division and chaos.

What other Chinese companies have influence potential like tiktok on US soil?
1. China doesn't own Bytedance. So they don't own the source. The fear our government has, is that the Chinese government could force them to share data and such. Yet, there is no evidence of that happening. Again, the same data that China can already get from other sources.
2. the influence of facebook, twitter, youtube, and other US media goes well beyond capitalsim, I wouldn't even consider it being the top motivator anymore. If you question that, all you have to do is look at the state of our politics in this country, and all the various catagories that fall under political topics that are running rampent on facebook, twitter, national news, and other US media sources.

Considering most of the content watched in the US is created by US citizens, how exactly is tik tok influencing us, or pushing foriegn idiology? is it taking control of the content creators and forcing them to create videos with hidden messages? Is it only letting people see the content that supporst right wing nut job views, or left wing views? Do you even understand how tik tok's algorithm works (The user's actions is what dictates what content they see)

to answer the quesion on what other Chinese companies have influence potential like tiktok, you have to first define what you consider dangerous to the US population and can cause serious damage to them and/or the US's stability, security, and economy. What influenences are you afraid of though? Is it the people who speak out about the US government's lies and manipulation, and tell us what the government doesn't want us to hear, and debunk a lot of shit, all coming from US citizens on tik tok? Is that the influene you are afraid of, and the very reason the US government is against tik tok? Is it the political influence, and political manipulation that is already rampant on facebook and twitter?

Personally, I am more concerned about the companies that have direct influence on our economy and our basic necessitites for survival. Lets take G.E. for example, with all the various industries they are involved in from smart devices to AeroSpace.. how do you think they can influence nearly every US citizen and effect our basic survival? Are you aware G.E. is owned by the Chinese, the 33rd largest company in the united states? What about all the Chinese companies that are part of our financial system, food supply, energy, etc? What kind of an influence do you think they have on the US? you are worried about people getting knowledge or the lack there of (influence) from tik tok, yet you are ignoring the real dangers around us that has full government approval. Maybe the US should ban the internet because it's the real vehicle used for influencing people. what do you think?
 
Last edited:

Drach

Golden Member
Apr 24, 2022
1,041
1,666
106
The Chinese didn't not buy GE.
They (Haier) bought the GE Appliance division
in 2016 for around 5B back in 2016. Not the whole company.

And every piece of shit they manufactured since then has been shit!
Ask me how I know.
2 microwaves down. A spendy refrigerator in the garbage heap.
An oven that doesn't work anymore.
Congrats China ,you have proved you are a worthless trade partner with the US.
I am ashamed to have stuck with GE.
 
Last edited:

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
23,258
12,889
136
Evidence to the contrary? See that's the problem, you and other's are running with what the US government is saying could happen, with no evidence that it is happening at all.


1. China doesn't own Bytedance. So they don't own the source. The fear our government has, is that the Chinese government could force them to share data and such. Yet, there is no evidence of that happening. Again, the same data that China can already get from other sources.
2. the influence of facebook, twitter, youtube, and other US media goes well beyond capitalsim, I wouldn't even consider it being the top motivator anymore. If you question that, all you have to do is look at the state of our politics in this country, and all the various catagories that fall under political topics that are running rampent on facebook, twitter, national news, and other US media sources.

Considering most of the content watched in the US is created by US citizens, how exactly is tik tok influencing us, or pushing foriegn idiology? is it taking control of the content creators and forcing them to create videos with hidden messages? Is it only letting people see the content that supporst right wing nut job views, or left wing views? Do you even understand how tik tok's algorithm works (The user's actions is what dictates what content they see)

to answer the quesion on what other Chinese companies have influence potential like tiktok, you have to first define what you consider dangerous to the US population and can cause serious damage to them and/or the US's stability, security, and economy. What influenences are you afraid of though? Is it the people who speak out about the US government's lies and manipulation, and tell us what the government doesn't want us to hear, and debunk a lot of shit, all coming from US citizens on tik tok? Is that the influene you are afraid of, and the very reason the US government is against tik tok? Is it the political influence, and political manipulation that is already rampant on facebook and twitter?

Personally, I am more concerned about the companies that have direct influence on our economy and our basic necessitites for survival. Lets take G.E. for example, with all the various industries they are involved in from smart devices to AeroSpace.. how do you think they can influence nearly every US citizen and effect our basic survival? Are you aware G.E. is owned by the Chinese, the 33rd largest company in the united states? What about all the Chinese companies that are part of our financial system, food supply, energy, etc? What kind of an influence do you think they have on the US? you are worried about people getting knowledge or the lack there of (influence) from tik tok, yet you are ignoring the real dangers around us that has full government approval. Maybe the US should ban the internet because it's the real vehicle used for influencing people. what do you think?
I think all Chinese companies are potential vectors, yes. Much like Russia.

No. In terms of influence I am not worried about objective truths or subjective interpretations of that, what I am concerned about is targeted psyops operations amplifying racism antiwax anti-institutional rhetoric anti immigrant hunter bidens dickpics etc… And owning your own massive social media platform surely makes that easier.
Its what Russia is doing. I am not saying China is doing it right now, but…
 
Reactions: Fanatical Meat

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
I think all Chinese companies are potential vectors, yes. Much like Russia.

No. In terms of influence I am not worried about objective truths or subjective interpretations of that, what I am concerned about is targeted psyops operations amplifying racism antiwax anti-institutional rhetoric anti immigrant hunter bidens dickpics etc… And owning your own massive social media platform surely makes that easier.
Its what Russia is doing. I am not saying China is doing it right now, but…
You mean exactly what is already happening with all US based media outlets from facebook to our national news media outlets, which has been taking place long before tik tok, with facebook having 3 times the user base tik tok has? The China Goverment does not own tik tok, That is a misconception that is fueling the fear around tik tok, spread by our government and those that are spreading the same misinformation. The China goverment is invested in it, thru what is called golden shares, which amounts to about 1%, and pretty much is required by most businesses in China who need access to the internet. China law also requires most chinese companies to share data and intelligence. So why is tik tok being singled out and non of those other businesses are being targeted? When you come to grips with the real reason, Which is our government wanting to silence people they don't want to be heard and call them out on their lies, you will understand why banning tik tok is dangerious and not the best interest of our citizens. You argue that China has banned Facebook and twitter. The irony of that argument is mind boggling, because China does it so they can control their citizens. And you want the same thing to happen in the US, more so than it already is. You are basically saying you want the US to be like China.

The point is banning tik tok won't change anything about China or other foreign influences, even if evidence ever surfaces of it taking place, as it's not even close to the level of influence that is already taking place thru the larger media outlets in the country already (facebook, twitter, youtube, national news media) by foreign entities including China. It also won't even make a scratch in what data the China government collects as it's available from hundreds, if not thousands of other source thru US companies by legal avenues, and every other company that is invested in and/or owned by China in the US because of China's data and intelligence laws. It amounts to trying to throwing a grain of rice at starvation from the perspective of influence and data collection. Tik tok however, has a huge impact on the lies and manipulation that is spread by our government. That is the reason why our government wants it banned, which will happen because it is already known that the China government will not allow it to be sold to a US company.
 
Last edited:

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
The Chinese didn't not buy GE.
They (Haier) bought the GE Appliance division
in 2016 for around 5B back in 2016. Not the whole company.

You are correct, sorry. But with all the smart technology in appliances now days, what kind of impact and oportunities, do you think that has on data collection, and how they use it to influence the US population? It really is a pointless argument though when we have Chinese investments in companies involved in every aspect of our economy and basic needs for survival, all with our government's approval.
 
Last edited:

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
Good enough reason to ban TicTok.

Yet, you are useing Youtube, one of the companies along with Meta/facebook, pushing for Tik Tok to be banned, which does the exact same thing. Heck, even google and other search engines, reddit, etc do it as well. But yeah, lets get ride of tik tok for doing the same thing facebook, youtube, and other media has been doing far longer than tik tok.. But thanks for putting the hypocrisy on full display.
 

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
23,258
12,889
136
You mean exactly what is already happening with all US based media outlets from facebook to our national news media outlets, which has been taking place long before tik tok, with facebook having 3 times the user base tik tok has? The China Goverment does not own tik tok, That is a misconception that is fueling the fear around tik tok, spread by our government and those that are spreading the same misinformation. The China goverment is invested in it, thru what is called golden shares, which amounts to about 1%, and pretty much is required by most businesses in China who need access to the internet. China law also requires most chinese companies to share data and intelligence. So why is tik tok being singled out and non of those other businesses are being targeted? When you come to grips with the real reason, Which is our government wanting to silence people they don't want to be heard and call them out on their lies, you will understand why banning tik tok is dangerious and not the best interest of our citizens. You argue that China has banned Facebook and twitter. The irony of that argument is mind boggling, because China does it so they can control their citizens. And you want the same thing to happen in the US, more so than it already is. You are basically saying you want the US to be like China.

The point is banning tik tok won't change anything about China or other foreign influences, even if evidence ever surfaces of it taking place, as it's not even close to the level of influence that is already taking place thru the larger media outlets in the country already (facebook, twitter, youtube, national news media) by foreign entities including China. It also won't even make a scratch in what data the China government collects as it's available from hundreds, if not thousands of other source thru US companies by legal avenues, and every other company that is invested in and/or owned by China in the US because of China's data and intelligence laws. It amounts to trying to throwing a grain of rice at starvation from the perspective of influence and data collection. Tik tok however, has a huge impact on the lies and manipulation that is spread by our government. That is the reason why our government wants it banned, which will happen because it is already known that the China government will not allow it to be sold to a US company.

TikTok notifications FTW.

 

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
TikTok notifications FTW.

Notifications FTW? You mean like what Youtube, Facebook, google, Microsoft, reddit, news media, even interenet providers, who all have the capability of doing so, and have done as well? Not necessarily directed at what our government is doing, but they all have utilized forced notifications. What's funny, is I never recieved such notification from Tik Tok.. why is that, if it's such a problem? But, the real question is, what's your issue with a company, trying to protect their brand, letting their users know that the US government is unjustly going after them, other than the fact it's Tik Tok? It's like you are obliviouls of what's happening around you, and has been happening long before Tik Tok.

I also find it interesting, you latched onto notifications, Which is pretty much meaningless as I pointed out why above, but appear to have ignored the rest of what Beau said in that video. He he pretty much said what @brycejones and for the most part, what I have said.

Now, lets go back to what Baeu said about the notification, and how users of tik tok found out about the government trying to ban them, and basically bombarded those in Congress with calls to not do so. Which seemed to make them want to speed up the process. That highlights the reason the government wants them sold or banned, but not for the reason you think. It's not that they sent out a notification, it's the fact that they told on the government. As the government was going to do it quietly, without us knowing, just like many laws they have passed without our knowledge, until it's to late. That's why the government wants them sold. Because at this current time, they can't stop those on tik tok, or tik tok themselves, from telling the truth about the shady shit our government is doing, that they don't want us to know about, or exposing their lies and manipulation. That is ultimatly and real reason they are going after tik tok. It's a threat to those in power, and interfers with them being able to control us as easily, and makes it more difficult for them to keep things from the US citizens, that we should know.
 
Last edited:

hal2kilo

Lifer
Feb 24, 2009
23,463
10,348
136
The Chinese didn't not buy GE.
They (Haier) bought the GE Appliance division
in 2016 for around 5B back in 2016. Not the whole company.

My dryer just died the other day and it was a GE and it worked for 14 years. So I was kind of stuck on getting another GE. Then I saw another deal for an LG that also qualified for the power company rebates, so I ordered it instead. I did not know that GE appliances were bought out by China. Not American, but not Chinese.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
58,192
12,369
136
Tik tok however, has a huge impact on the lies and manipulation that is spread by our government. That is the reason why our government wants it banned, which will happen because it is already known that the China government will not allow it to be sold to a US company.
Does it? Really? Is there some special thing happening on Tik Tok that couldn't also happen on many other internet platforms that the US government is not trying to ban? Can you provide any examples? What's happening on Tik Tok that couldn't happen on Mastodon, or Discord, etc?
 
Reactions: Indus

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
23,258
12,889
136
Notifications FTW? You mean like what Youtube, Facebook, google, Microsoft, reddit, news media, even interenet providers, who all have the capability of doing so, and have done as well? Not necessarily directed at what our government is doing, but they all have utilized forced notifications. What's funny, is I never recieved such notification from Tik Tok.. why is that, if it's such a problem? But, the real question is, what's your issue with a company, trying to protect their brand, letting their users know that the US government is unjustly going after them, other than the fact it's Tik Tok? It's like you are obliviouls of what's happening around you, and has been happening long before Tik Tok.

I also find it interesting, you latched onto notifications, Which is pretty much meaningless as I pointed out why above, but appear to have ignored the rest of what Beau said in that video. He he pretty much said what @brycejones and for the most part, what I have said.

Now, lets go back to what Baeu said about the notification, and how users of tik tok found out about the government trying to ban them, and basically bombarded those in Congress with calls to not do so. Which seemed to make them want to speed up the process. That highlights the reason the government wants them sold or banned, but not for the reason you think. It's not that they sent out a notification, it's the fact that they told on the government. As the government was going to do it quietly, without us knowing, just like many laws they have passed without our knowledge, until it's to late. That's why the government wants them sold. Because at this current time, they can't stop those on tik tok, or tik tok themselves, from telling the truth about the shady shit our government is doing, that they don't want us to know about, or exposing their lies and manipulation. That is ultimatly and real reason they are going after tik tok. It's a threat to those in power, and interfers with them being able to control us as easily, and makes it more difficult for them to keep things from the US citizens, that we should know.
Shit dude. None of this is going anywhere without common sense.
 
Reactions: Indus

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
Shit dude. None of this is going anywhere without common sense.
The common sense you seem to be lacking, and or not applying to all the other US companies, specially social Media? If you step back and apply common sense, you will realize Tik Tok is the least of the problems where China is concerned.
 

NWRMidnight

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,952
2,558
136
Does it? Really? Is there some special thing happening on Tik Tok that couldn't also happen on many other internet platforms that the US government is not trying to ban? Can you provide any examples? What's happening on Tik Tok that couldn't happen on Mastodon, or Discord, etc?
Actually yes. There is a lot of stuff that comes out about OUR government and large corporations, that is censored and/or removed on US based social media, on many different topics. What we see on US media is generally what what the government and large corporations wants us to hear.


People talk about th pressure the US government can and does put on US companies, not realizing the extent of that pressure that is directed at preventing the US population from finding things out about our government and large corporations, that they do not want us to know.

This topic is a good example. Why do you think the government wants Tik Tok sold to a US company or banned? So they have the ability to silence those they don't want heard. It has nothing to do with national security, protecting our privacy, data mining. Just about any topic can be used as an example: immigration, politics, economy, energy, inflation, oil/gas, legislation.. you name it. What we get from US companies is what they want us to hear, which is full of half truths and manipulation of facts a lot of the time.

People talk a out mis/dis information. Our government is the largest producer of such.
 
Last edited:

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
23,258
12,889
136
The common sense you seem to be lacking, and or not applying to all the other US companies, specially social Media? If you step back and apply common sense, you will realize Tik Tok is the least of the problems where China is concerned.

I dont like pointing out the obvious cause to me it’s testimony that were not really having a dialogue rather two monologues.
I brought up the Beau piece cause it was a nuanced take that had some of both of our positions.
I didnt, guess I still dont, know how easily obtainable these mass data dumps are and of what quality. It seem though its a bigger problem than I realized. I do not agree with Beau’s take that with a couple more steps they could do a similar influence operation via facebook as they could via tiktok. The data dumps are static. Via your own platform you get data realtime PLUS you control the algorithm.
- Realtime high resolution data
- Controlling the algorithm
- Plug in multiple AI’s
You remember how it was disclosed that Russia was organizing blm and anti-blm protest at the same time up to the 2016 election?
No I dont see the benefit of having an adversary plug in with a supercharged social media platform and abuse the internal mechanics of the democratic principles.

Yea other companies could in principle do the same except for the fact they’re not Chinese or Russian, are subject to domestic regulatory measures, revision and can be shut down with a court order. Fined. Whistleblowers. All kinds of checks and balances. Tiktok? Not so much.
 

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
23,258
12,889
136
Actually yes. There is a lot of stuff that comes out about OUR government and large corporations, that is censored and/or removed on US based social media, on many different topics. What we see on US media is generally what what the government and large corporations wants us to hear.


People talk about th pressure the US government can and does put on US companies, not realizing the extent of that pressure that is directed at preventing the US population from finding things out about our government and large corporations, that they do not want us to know.

This topic is a good example. Why do you think the government wants Tik Tok sold to a US company or banned? So they have the ability to silence those they don't want heard. It has nothing to do with national security, protecting our privacy, data mining. Just about any topic can be used as an example: immigration, politics, economy, energy, inflation, oil/gas, legislation.. you name it. What we get from US companies is what they want us to hear, which is full of half truths and manipulation of facts a lot of the time.

People talk a out mis/dis information. Our government is the largest producer of such.
Are you saying there is no free press in the US?
 
sale-70-410-exam    | Exam-200-125-pdf    | we-sale-70-410-exam    | hot-sale-70-410-exam    | Latest-exam-700-603-Dumps    | Dumps-98-363-exams-date    | Certs-200-125-date    | Dumps-300-075-exams-date    | hot-sale-book-C8010-726-book    | Hot-Sale-200-310-Exam    | Exam-Description-200-310-dumps?    | hot-sale-book-200-125-book    | Latest-Updated-300-209-Exam    | Dumps-210-260-exams-date    | Download-200-125-Exam-PDF    | Exam-Description-300-101-dumps    | Certs-300-101-date    | Hot-Sale-300-075-Exam    | Latest-exam-200-125-Dumps    | Exam-Description-200-125-dumps    | Latest-Updated-300-075-Exam    | hot-sale-book-210-260-book    | Dumps-200-901-exams-date    | Certs-200-901-date    | Latest-exam-1Z0-062-Dumps    | Hot-Sale-1Z0-062-Exam    | Certs-CSSLP-date    | 100%-Pass-70-383-Exams    | Latest-JN0-360-real-exam-questions    | 100%-Pass-4A0-100-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-300-135-exams-date    | Passed-200-105-Tech-Exams    | Latest-Updated-200-310-Exam    | Download-300-070-Exam-PDF    | Hot-Sale-JN0-360-Exam    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Exams    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-JN0-360-exams-date    | Exam-Description-1Z0-876-dumps    | Latest-exam-1Z0-876-Dumps    | Dumps-HPE0-Y53-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-HPE0-Y53-Exam    | 100%-Pass-HPE0-Y53-Real-Exam-Questions    | Pass-4A0-100-Exam    | Latest-4A0-100-Questions    | Dumps-98-365-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-98-365-Exam    | 100%-Pass-VCS-254-Exams    | 2017-Latest-VCS-273-Exam    | Dumps-200-355-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-300-320-Exam    | Pass-300-101-Exam    | 100%-Pass-300-115-Exams    |
http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    | http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    |