i watched Jim Jaramusch's claim to fame, Down By Law, or - with it's original release title -
Daunbailo' -
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0090967/reference/
I scream - you scream - we all scream for ice cream.
B&W 1986 film by JJ starring Tom Waits, John Lurie and Roberto Benigni. Essentially the plot is "what if you were locked up with an italian who
can't into english?"
Pimp "Jack" (Lurie) is set up by a business partner and busted with an underage girl. Disgraced ex- disk jockey "Zack" (Waits) is convinced to drive a hot car and gets busted with a body in the trunk. They are jailed together and inmate "Roberto" (Beningi) is put in their cell, for allegedly knocking unconscious a cop with a pool ball.
The main part of the story is Roberto being horrible at speaking english, but at the same time being a very charismatic guy. Makes friends with the other two and convinces them to escape from jail. Cut the Louisiana bayou and walking through mud, and more of the same: Roberto trying to communicate in his horribly broken english, and the other two laughing at this. Obviously the viewer is meant to identify with the two.
And, somehow this works. Benigni is a .. difficult artist. He does this part well, but it's also true he can't do anything else, he can only play THIS part.
How in the world Jaramusch figured out that combining this one absurd italian actor with two straight-man characters would be funny, is beyond me, but he did it.
I can't really tell how much of Roberto's dialogue is improv and what is scripted, but i'm happy to not know.
(apparently there is a major line of dialogue that Benigni could not deliver as he genuinely does not speak english, and they went with it and fitted the script to match what they had on tape)
Camera is very straightforward but not boring or dull.
The film does have some pacing issues and a tiny bit of trimming would probably improve it, but it's nothing like, let's say, Dead Man. It's also less of a mindfuck than Dead Man, whether that's a positive or a negative to you, i cannot say.
Some vague parallels with Oh Brother, but obviously Daunbailo' is a much simpler film. However, i wouldn't be surprised if the Cohen brothers were familiar with this film.
I liked it. Maybe you won't .. but i am sure
@zinfamous would love this.
My vote:
7/10 - it's an art film, judge it by its own merits.